A Common Pricing Mistake (and a 5-Minute Fix)

Revenue
8 min read

A Common Pricing Mistake (and a 5-Minute Fix)

Here’s an example of pricing gone wrong:

Illustrative example: The retired CPA in this story is a hypothetical example used to explain the idea, not a real client or customer, and no dollar results are claimed. Results vary and are never typical or guaranteed. See our Earnings Disclaimer.

A retired CPA created an incredible spreadsheet system for tracking small business expenses. Saved his clients thousands. Took him 30 years to perfect.

He packaged it up, wrote a simple sales page, and listed it at a bargain-bin price.

His thinking? “It’s just a spreadsheet. I can’t charge too much.”

Result: Zero sales in the first month.

He panicked. Dropped the price. Then dropped it again.

Still nothing.

Then I asked him one question that changed everything:

“How much money does your spreadsheet save the average business owner per year?”

His answer: “Probably thousands of dollars in tax deductions they’d otherwise miss.”

I suggested he raise the price to match the value and rewrite the sales page to focus on the savings, not the spreadsheet.

The new version finally started to sell.

Same product. Higher price. Better positioning. Completely different outcome.

Here’s what most new online business owners get catastrophically wrong about pricing—and how to fix it before you launch anything.

The Fatal Pricing Mistake (And Why You’re Probably Making It)

Most people price their products based on what they think people will pay, not the value they’re actually delivering.

This leads to three catastrophic errors:

Error #1: Pricing Too Low (The “Race to the Bottom”)

You think: “I’m new, so I should charge less to attract buyers.”

What actually happens:

  • Low prices signal low quality
  • Bargain hunters buy but never implement (then complain)
  • You need 10X more sales to hit your income goals
  • You attract price shoppers, not serious buyers

The psychology: When people see a $7 course on “How to Start a Consulting Business,” their brain thinks:

“If this actually worked, it would cost more. This must be basic/incomplete/scammy.”

Error #2: Pricing Based on “Stuff” Instead of Outcomes

You think: “It’s just 4 videos and a PDF, so I can’t charge much.”

Wrong.

Your customers don’t care about the number of videos. They care about what those videos help them achieve.

Bad pricing logic:

  • “4 videos + 1 PDF = $27”

Good pricing logic:

  • “System that helps retirees land their first 3 clients in 30 days = $297”

Same product. Different frame. 10X price difference.

Error #3: Being Afraid to Charge What You’re Worth

This is the big one.

You’ve got decades of experience. You’ve solved real problems. You know things other people desperately need to know.

But you think: “Who am I to charge $297? I’m not some big-name guru.”

Here’s the truth: Your customers don’t need you to be famous. They need you to solve their problem.

And if you can solve a $5,000 problem, charging $297 is a bargain—not a rip-off.

The Pricing Formula That Actually Works

Here’s the exact framework Kevin Fahey teaches for pricing any online product:

Step 1: Calculate the “Value Gap”

Ask yourself:

“What is the financial or emotional cost of my customer’s problem?”

Examples:

  • Retiree struggling to find clients → Lost income: $2,000/month = $24,000/year
  • Small business owner confused by bookkeeping → Potential IRS penalty: $5,000
  • Someone struggling with LinkedIn profile → Missed job opportunities: $60,000/year salary

Step 2: Position Your Product as the Bridge

Your price should be a small fraction of the value you deliver.

The formula:

  • If you solve a $5,000 problem → Charge $197-$497
  • If you solve a $24,000 problem → Charge $497-$1,997
  • If you solve a $60,000 problem → Charge $997-$4,997

Why this works:

  • Customers see massive ROI (10X-50X return)
  • You’re positioned as premium and valuable
  • You attract serious buyers who will actually implement

Step 3: Use the “Price Point Ladder” Strategy

From Kevin’s 50K Case Study framework, here are the proven price points that convert:

Low-Ticket Entry Products:

  • $17 (minimum—anything lower signals “cheap”)
  • $27 (sweet spot for impulse buys)
  • $47 (great for mini-courses/challenges)

Mid-Ticket Core Products:

  • $97 (comprehensive courses)
  • $147-$197 (flagship courses with implementation)
  • $297 (premium courses/group programs)

High-Ticket Transformation Products:

  • $497-$997 (coaching + course bundles)
  • $1,997-$4,997 (group coaching/masterminds)
  • $5,000+ (1-on-1 coaching/done-for-you)

Pro Tip from Kevin: The $7 front-end price is too low. It attracts tire-kickers and kills conversions on upsells. Start at $17 minimum.

Example: How Repositioning Can Change Results

Here’s another example:

Illustrative example: The retired project manager below is a hypothetical example used to explain the idea, not a real client or customer, and no dollar results are claimed. Results vary and are never typical or guaranteed. See our Earnings Disclaimer.

Background:

  • Retired project manager (age 58) teaching small business owners how to manage remote teams
  • Original product: “Remote Team Management Toolkit”
  • Original price: a low impulse-buy price
  • Sales in first 90 days: slow

The Intervention:

I asked him: “What does bad remote team management cost a business owner?”

His answer:

  • Miscommunication = Missed deadlines = Lost clients
  • Poor productivity = Wasted payroll (est. $10,000/year)
  • High turnover = Recruiting costs (est. $15,000/year)
  • Total cost of the problem: ~$25,000/year

The Changes:

  1. Renamed the product: “The Remote Team System: Never Lose Another Client to Miscommunication”
  2. Repositioned the offer: Focused on the cost of NOT fixing the problem
  3. Changed the price: raised it to reflect the value
  4. Added a payment plan: 3 monthly payments
  5. Included a bonus: 30-minute implementation call

New Results (next 90 days):

  • More buyers, even at the higher price
  • Some buyers chose the payment plan
  • A few upgraded to group coaching

Same person. Same expertise.

The only difference? Pricing and positioning.

The “Confidence Pricing” Method (For When You’re Starting Out)

I get it—you’re thinking: “But I’m new! I don’t have testimonials or a track record yet!”

Fair. Here’s how to price confidently even when you’re just starting:

Strategy #1: The “Founder’s Pricing” Model

Launch at a discount for the first 10-20 buyers in exchange for feedback and testimonials.

Example:

  • Regular price: $297
  • Founder’s price: $97 (for first 15 buyers)
  • Condition: They provide a testimonial and honest feedback

Why this works:

  • You still position yourself as premium ($297 anchor)
  • Early buyers get a deal and feel special
  • You build social proof quickly
  • After 15 sales, you raise to full price with testimonials in hand

Strategy #2: The “Guarantee That Removes All Risk” Method

Charge your full price ($197-$497) but offer an iron-clad guarantee:

Examples:

  • “Get your first client in 30 days or I’ll refund you AND give you a free 1-on-1 coaching call”
  • “If you don’t save at least $1,000 using this system, I’ll refund every penny”

Why this works:

  • The guarantee removes the buyer’s risk
  • You can charge premium prices without the “proven track record”
  • Refund rates are typically <5% if your product delivers value

Strategy #3: The “Pay What You Want (Above $X)” Model

Set a minimum price ($97) and let buyers choose to pay more.

Example:

  • Minimum: $97
  • Suggested: $197
  • Premium: $297 (includes bonus coaching call)

Why this works:

  • Removes pricing objections
  • Customers self-select into their value perception
  • Surprisingly, 20-30% pay ABOVE the minimum

The Pricing Psychology Secrets Nobody Talks About

Here are the insider tricks that make your pricing irresistible:

Trick #1: The “Anchoring” Effect

Show a higher reference price next to your sale price: a crossed-out “regular” price only if you have actually charged it, or else the real value or what the alternative costs (e.g. “A consultant charges $497 for this”).

Example:

  • → $197 (launch price, ends Friday at midnight CT)

Only use urgency when the deadline or limit is real; fake scarcity erodes trust. If you say the launch price ends Friday, raise it on Friday.

Why it works: The brain sees $197 as a bargain compared to a real $497 alternative. Never cross out a “regular” price you have never charged; that is a misleading claim, and it erodes trust.

Trick #2: The “Decoy” Price

Offer three pricing tiers. Make the middle one the most attractive.

Example:

  • Basic: $97 (course only)
  • Premium: $297 (course + group coaching + bonuses) ← MOST POPULAR
  • VIP: $997 (course + 1-on-1 coaching + implementation)

Why it works: Most people avoid the cheapest option (feels incomplete) and the most expensive (feels excessive). The middle option becomes the “obvious choice.”

Trick #3: The “Pain of Paying” Reducer

Break big prices into small daily/weekly costs.

Example: Instead of saying “$297 for the course,” say:

“Less than $1/day for the next year to master remote team management”

Why it works: $297 feels big. $1/day feels trivial.

The “Price Test” Checklist (Use This Before You Launch)

Before you finalize your price, ask yourself these 5 questions:

✅ Does my price reflect the OUTCOME, not the deliverables?

  • ❌ “3 videos for $27”
  • ✅ “$297 to land your first 3 clients in 30 days”

✅ Would I pay this price to solve this problem?

  • If your answer is “no,” your price is either too high OR your offer isn’t compelling enough

✅ Does my price attract serious buyers?

  • $7-$17 = Tire-kickers
  • $97-$297 = Serious learners
  • $497+ = Action-takers who will implement

✅ Can I deliver 10X value vs. what I’m charging?

  • If you’re charging $197, can you deliver $1,970 in value? If yes, you’re golden.

✅ Am I pricing based on fear or confidence?

  • Fear = “I hope someone buys this”
  • Confidence = “This will change their life, and $297 is a steal”

The Bottom Line

Underpricing doesn’t make you generous—it makes you invisible.

Premium pricing doesn’t make you greedy—it makes you credible.

Your decades of experience, your hard-won knowledge, your ability to solve real problems—that has value.

Don’t insult your expertise (or your customers) by charging $27 for a solution to a $25,000 problem.

Charge what you’re worth. Deliver 10X the value. Watch what happens.

Ready to Price Your Offer for Maximum Profit and Impact?

Get the free guide, Your Experience Has Value: seven legitimate ways retirees earn online, explained in plain language with no hype.

👉 Get the free guide here →

Some links on this site may be affiliate links; if you buy through one, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. See our Affiliate Disclosure. Any income examples are illustrative, not typical or guaranteed. See our Earnings Disclaimer.

Get the Weekly Rewiring Report

One practical, no-hype idea a week for building your second act. Unsubscribe anytime.

Free. Unsubscribe anytime. We never share your email. See our Privacy Policy.

Share this
Written by Bob Moore